The Use of Deliberate Practice to Obtain Better Results in Musical Performance

Professional musicians and music students alike seek ways to optimize their practice sessions and achieve more effective results. One powerful methodology is deliberate practice, a term coined by psychologist K. Anders Ericsson to describe a focused and systematic approach to training. Unlike routine practice, which may involve mindless repetition, deliberate practice demands concentrated attention on specific goals aimed at improving performance. Drawing on the book Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise (2016) by Ericsson and Robert Pool, this discussion explores the definition of deliberate practice, its requirements, and how musicians can apply it to their study routine for dramatically enhanced outcomes.

What Is Deliberate Practice?

The term deliberate practice was introduced by researcher and psychologist K. Anders Ericsson (1947–2020) to describe the focused, consistent, and goal-oriented training that top performers use to refine their skills. Ericsson devoted his career to understanding the psychological underpinnings of expertise and performance, studying experts in fields like medicine, music, chess, and sports to uncover how they achieve superior results.

Society has long been fascinated by individuals with exceptional talents, whose achievements far surpass those of the average person. Many theories attempt to explain why some people show extraordinary abilities. One enduring justification is the idea of innate talent or gift—the belief that a person is born predisposed to play the piano, for instance. If we ask teachers whether they have encountered students who display a remarkable knack for a subject, most would likely answer yes. Yet the critical question is the long-term impact of such early facility. Without proper, focused practice, the chances that a student will develop mastery are minimal, according to recent research.

The discovery of DNA in 1953 opened new avenues for understanding genetic predisposition and innate talent. Over time, studies have found that the link between talent and genes is weak at best. The one clear physical attribute that can offer a performance advantage—depending on the domain—is height.

The notion that high IQ correlates with exceptional achievement has also been challenged. Researchers examining the IQs of chess masters concluded that there is no relationship between a player's tournament results and their IQ level.

Challenging long-held beliefs about talent is difficult. Presenting the idea that expertise is cultivated—not simply inherited—raises many questions and often brings up historical geniuses who were supposedly blessed with unique gifts. In music, a classic example is Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Considered a prodigy in his own time, Mozart began composing around age five, toured Europe performing for royalty at age six, and wrote his first opera by twelve. He left behind over 600 compositions that reshaped the music of his era. Yet when we examine Mozart through the lens of deliberate practice, his genius appears less as raw talent and more as the product of an intensely dedicated life.

A closer look at Mozart's biography reveals key facts. At age four, he began intensive musical training under his father, Leopold Mozart, a violinist, composer, and one of Europe's leading pedagogues. Frequent public performances built Mozart's experience, confidence, and professional network. Although his earliest compositions date back to childhood, many musicologists consider the 14th Piano Concerto in E-flat Major (K.449) from 1784 to be his first truly “mature” work. That means twenty-four years passed between his first attempt at composition and his first widely recognized work—two and a half decades of composing, practicing, and refining his craft until the world acclaimed him as a genius.

The 10,000-Hour Rule and Its Misinterpretation

In a pioneering 1993 study, Ericsson analyzed a group of violinists at the Berlin Academy. He found that the most accomplished students—those closest to professional levels—had accumulated roughly 10,000 hours of focused practice since beginning music. Journalist Malcolm Gladwell popularized this finding as the “10,000-hour rule” in his book Outliers, asserting that it takes ten thousand hours of practice to become a master in most fields.

While time invested in any skill clearly correlates with results, it is not the hours alone that elevate performance. A key factor is how those hours are used. Aubrey Daniels offers a vivid basketball analogy: Two players each practice free throws for an hour. Player A takes 200 shots with a colleague retrieving the ball, recording each make or miss and the nature of any miss (short, long, left, right). Player B shoots only 50 shots, collects the ball, talks with friends, and generally does not focus. After 100 hours, which player will likely improve more? Ericsson himself took issue with Gladwell's oversimplification, calling it an “often incorrect interpretation” of his research.

Understanding the Practice Process

When we learn something new—cooking, for instance—we quickly develop a routine: asking a skilled friend for tips, watching YouTube videos, and gathering essential tools. We test and re-test recipes; initial results are imperfect, but gradually we achieve satisfaction. The activity becomes automatic. Ericsson notes that it is normal to reach an average, functional level for many activities, but once you stabilize at that level, progress stops. Yet people often assume that more years of experience automatically mean greater expertise—a long-time driver must be better than a novice. Studies reveal the contrary; the seasoned driver's mechanical skills may actually erode without continual efforts to improve.

Purposeful Practice vs. Naive Practice

The path to improvement relies on understanding different kinds of practice. Naive practice is what many people do most of the time: repeating familiar actions on autopilot. They are practicing, but not necessarily advancing. Purposeful practice, by contrast, is thoughtful, deliberate, and focused. It involves clear specific goals, sustained concentration, immediate feedback, a willingness to step out of one's comfort zone, and creative problem solving. It also requires maintaining motivation and confronting genuine mental challenges along the way.

True deliberate practice has two essential principles. First, the field itself must be well-defined and rigorous, with clear distinctions between experts and novices. Music, chess, and sports fit this description. Even if your area does not meet this threshold, the general principles of deliberate practice can still help you develop as far as possible. The second principle is the need for a teacher or coach who can structure the practice plan and guide you toward the next level.

Deliberate Practice Applied to Music

Music may be the ideal field for applying deliberate practice. It is fiercely competitive, and training methods have evolved for hundreds of years. Instruments such as violin and piano demand years of focused work even to reach the upper echelons.

With the principles of deliberate practice established, the question is how musicians can integrate them into their daily study and performance. The truth is that talent alone is insufficient; what separates the great from the good is a long, intensive, and laser-focused effort. Instead of asking, “Am I talented enough?” musicians should ask, “Am I willing to do the work?”

Ericsson argued that the true gift required for expertise is adaptability. According to the Cambridge Dictionary, adaptability is the “ability or willingness to change to suit different conditions.” Practically, this means it is a mindset oriented toward challenge, growth, and daring; it involves leaving comfort zones, questioning limits, and seeking opportunities for personal and professional development. Musicians ready to cultivate deliberate practice will need to embrace this adaptability in their study routine.

Getting Ready to Practice

The first step is to leave autopilot behind and create a truly purposeful practice session. That means knowing exactly why you are practicing and what you want to improve—which brings us back to the need for a skilled teacher. A good teacher provides small, specific goals to refine aspects of your playing, identifies weak spots, and designs strategies to address them. Finding such a mentor requires diligent research; not all great performers know how to teach well. When evaluating potential tutors, observe their teaching style and check their track record with students.

Lessons with an excellent teacher can be costly, so every moment should be maximized. Before the lesson, organize your questions and challenges. Record the session (with permission), then listen back and transcribe key points. This process helps the brain assimilate the material. Below is a visual roadmap of the deliberate practice process.

Following the roadmap, after selecting your teacher, the next step is an honest self-assessment. Write down your current limits: achievements, failures, technical difficulties, performance obstacles, and the nature of your practice routine and previous instruction. The more specific you are, the clearer your goals and strategies will become.

Setting Specific Goals

A well-defined goal is the endpoint you are moving toward. When your goal is clear, you will avoid wasting energy on irrelevant練習(training) that leads nowhere. For example, winning an orchestra audition demands a study system that leaves no excerpt unmastered by the audition day. Ericsson described purposeful practice as “putting a bunch of baby steps together to reach a longer-term goal, breaking it down, and making a plan.”

Maintaining Focused Practice

Once goals and a plan are in place, focused practice becomes easier. A simple but critical rule: in the practice room, your cell phone belongs in airplane mode. The urge to check notifications causes cognitive disruption, shattering concentration. Studies on attention span suggest the brain can hold focus for a finite period—typically no more than ninety minutes before a break is needed.

If you hit a stumbling block during practice, do not plow through it forcefully. Isolate the problematic passage, slow it down until you can truly see where the difficulty lies, then build exercises to solve that specific stretch. only then—when you can execute it correctly at a slow tempo multiple times—should you consider the problem addressed.

Receiving and Using Feedback

Ericsson noted that “you need feedback to identify exactly where and how you are failing.” Without feedback—from yourself or someone else—you cannot assess progress or identify gaps. In initial stages, the teacher provides the bulk of feedback, but over time you develop the ability to self-critique and improve. The purpose is always to isolate what is not working, determine why, and create a targeted solution.

Music students typically meet their teacher once a week, but feedback should happen daily. A highly effective technique is self-recording. Recording oneself is an old habit in music, yet frustratingly few students exploit it thoroughly. A recording provides an impartial, full-perspective view, reveals details you would miss while playing, and builds discipline under pressure. Another strong method is to arrange mock auditions or run simulated performances for friends, classmates, or musicians from other disciplines. Ask for honest, kind, and specific critique. Remember that unkind or vague comments serve no purpose.

Developing Mental Representations

Ericsson defined a mental representation as “a mental structure that corresponds to an object, an idea, a collection of information, or anything else, concrete or abstract, that the brain is thinking about it.” These representations operate both consciously and unconsciously. Over time, with consistent practice and observation, patterns and solutions become internalized, allowing you to access them without conscious thought. A deep lattice of mental representations underpins the best performances in music.

Long-term memories remain constantly accessible, so they can be recalled using a memorial retrieval structure.

Mental representation takes information learned previously and applies it to the task at hand. In music, after studying fundamentals for years—such as scales and their combinations—you build mental representations. When encountering a new piece, you recognize these patterns and play through it much faster. This means you can deliberately construct mental representations to solve current problems, providing a foundation for creative ideas.

In music, representation arises from prior knowledge. When you already have the music in your mind, having heard it, you know precisely how you want to play it—what expressions, tempos, dynamics, and other details to use. The mental representation of context is also vital, whether on audition day, in competition, or during a performance. For example, when preparing for an audition, mentally mapping out the day—considering possible orders in which excerpts might be requested, the weather forecast, audition timing to estimate traffic, and nearby places to eat—can yield advantages (Harcourt, 2016, 58).

Since mental representation builds on prior knowledge, try to learn about the audition venue ahead of time. Familiarity with the visual and acoustic environment will help you feel more at ease.

#### Maintain Motivation

Maintaining constant, purposeful practice while pushing beyond your comfort zone is not always easy. Loss of motivation is one reason people stop progressing. When first learning an instrument, recognizing improvement comes naturally—each new skill feels rewarding and encourages continued practice. But once you reach a solid level and strive for excellence, progress slows because the gap between these stages demands far more specialized practice. The path to the top is rarely fun and requires intense dedication and focus. Staying motivated is crucial to avoid quitting halfway, for though the work is hard, the effort will prove worthwhile.

To sustain motivation during practice, recall the reasons driving you to improve. Listen to your favorite songs, watch musicians who inspire you, celebrate small daily victories, and remember that being a musician demands extensive mental and physical work—so pay attention to your diet and sleep quality. Another key tip: stay connected with supportive people. Belonging to communities and groups committed to achieving their best performance will help you remain focused on your goals.

#### Conclusion

Deliberate practice is specific, focused practice aimed at improving performance and reaching expertise in one's field. Two factors are essential for its optimal application: a well-defined domain, such as music, sports, or chess, and a skilled teacher who can guide the student in overcoming difficulties.

Applying deliberate practice in music is entirely possible and easy to understand, yet difficult to carry out. It demands great dedication from the musician to maintain consistency. Still, all the effort is justified because only through intense, targeted practice can one reach the top of a field as competitive as music.

#### Bibliography

Bonneville-Roussy, Arielle, and Thérèse Bouffard. “When Quantity Is Not Enough: Disentangling the Roles of Practice Time, Self-Regulation and Deliberate Practice in Musical Achievement.” Psychology of Music 43, no. 5 (September 2015): 686–704.

Cahill Clark, Jennifer L. "String Student Self-Efficacy and Deliberate Music Practice: Examining String Students' Musical Background Characteristics, Self-Efficacy Beliefs, and Practice Behaviors." Order No. 3352078, University of North Texas, 2008.

Clear, James. Atomic Habits: An Easy and Proven Way to Build Good Habits and Break Bad Ones. Random House, 2019.

Colvin, Geoffrey. Talent Is Overrated: What Really Separates World-Class Performers from Everybody Else. Nicholas Brealey, 2008.

Coyle, Daniel. The Talent Code: Greatness Isn't Born. It's Grown. Bantam Dell, 2009.

Ericsson, K. Anders, and Kyle W. Harwell. “Deliberate Practice and Proposed Limits on the Effects of Practice on the Acquisition of Expert Performance: Why the Original Definition Matters and Recommendations for Future Research.” Frontiers in Psychology 10 (2019).

Ericsson, K. Anders, and Robert Pool. Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2016.

Ericsson, K. Anders, and Jerad H. Moxley. “The Expert Performance Approach and Deliberate Practice.” Handbook of Organizational Creativity, 2012, pp. 141–167.

Ericsson, K. Anders, Krampe and Ralf Thomas. “Deliberate Practice and Elite Musical Performance.” In The Practice of Performance: Studies in Musical Interpretation, (1993): 84–104.

Gladwell, Malcolm. Outliers: The Story of Success. Boston: Little Brown & Company, 2008.

Iqbal, Azlan. “Knowledge Discovery in Chess Using an Aesthetics Approach.” The Journal of Aesthetic Education 46, no. 1 (February 15, 2012): 73–90.

Landon, Howard C. Robbins. Mozart - Die Wiener Jahre: 1781-1791. Stuttgart: Dt. Bücherbund, 1991.

Lordo, Jackie. "Expertise Development in Musicians: The Roles of Deliberate Play and Deliberate Practice." Missouri Journal of Research in Music Education (2014): 61.

Macnamara, Brooke N., and Megha Maitra. “The Role of Deliberate Practice in Expert Performance: Revisiting Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Römer (1993).” Royal Society Open Science, vol. 6, no. 8, 2019.

Meinz, Elizabeth J., and David Z. Hambrick. "Deliberate Practice Is Necessary but Not Sufficient to Explain Individual Differences in Piano Sight-Reading Skill: The Role of Working Memory Capacity." Psychological Science 21, no. 7 (2010): 914-19.

Newport, Cal. Deep Work: Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World. Grand Central Pub, 2016.

Pope, James L. "Motivation Factors in Mastery-Oriented Instrumental Learning and Performing." Culminating Projects in Teacher Development 50, 2017.

Rainero, Ruth. "Practicing Vocal Music Efficiently and Effectively: Applying 'Deliberate Practice' to a New Piece of Music." Journal of Singing - the Official Journal of the National Association of Teachers of Singing 69, no. 2 (11, 2012): 203-214.

Sterner, Thomas M. The Practicing Mind: Developing Focus and Discipline in Your Life: Master Any Skill or Challenge by Learning to Love the Process. New World Library, 2012.

Syed, Matthew. Bounce: The Myth of Talent and the Power of Practice. HarperCollins, 2010.

Waitzkin, Josh. The Art of Learning: A Journey in the Pursuit of Excellence. Simon & Schuster, 2007.

#### Web Sources

“Adaptability: Definition in the Cambridge English Dictionary.” Cambridge English Dictionary. Accessed December 5, 2020. .

“Expert Performance: Apologies to Dr. Ericsson, But It Is Not 10,000 Hours of Deliberate Practice.” Aubrey Daniels International, September 21, 2018. .

“How to Use Deliberate Practice to Reach the Top 1% of Your Field.” Nat Eliason, December 1, 2020. .

“The Discovery of DNA.” Stories. The Public Engagement team at the Wellcome Genome Campus, February 26, 2018. .